Search results for query: *

I read brodie grundy was a Carlton supporter. Also remember reading nic nat went for collingwood

Just voting on the pies players in contention for the top 50. It's hard enough for me to rate the players from my team let alone the opposition:p

My Votes vs GCS 9- Thomas 8- Beams 7- Cloke 6- Pendles (very good before he went off imo) 5- Sidey

I was gonna go (Pies players only) 9- Beams 8- Pendlebury, Sidebottom, Thomas 7- Shaw 2- Cloke So yeah, I reckon you've gotten it pretty close. A 0 is too harsh though imo. On the other hand, i thinks 10's should be reserved for the truly outstanding games (e.g Ablett earlier this year).

There's no way J-Pod is in the top 50 players in the competition this year, other than that good work.

Bradshaw? From pies Swan Pendles Didak Shaw take your pick for no.5

Very good list but Cox at 39? Has he been injured or something?

Switch Bucks with Brown and it's a pretty accurate list.

Good work AG, damn hard thing to do. From a Collingwood POV, Davis, Presti, probably too high. Didak too low imo. I know he's missed a fair few games but has had so many BOG's to make up for it. I guess it comes down to how you judge it. Shaw and O'Brien must be very, very close.