Search results for query: *

Nothing alike, Ziebell's sole intent was to put Joseph into tomorrow while Viney had no other option but to collide with Lynch.

Lets spare a thought for the real victims in all of this - Norh fans. No longer can they cry and claim Ziebell's suspension was the worst in tribunals history.

no, you

Agree, the OP didn't have to venture down the path of the Vics are out to get us. But Buddy should count his lucky stars as should Kosi for receiving only three down to two weeks for one of the most deliberate and deplorable snipes of the last couple of years.

while Moloney's hit wasn't even reviewed

Re: Selwood gets off! People are entitled to hate Selwood for his ducking antics but he has nothing to do with this decision. MRP tried to hang Lindsay Thomas for an accidental contact and now they've excused Selwood for a deliberate action. What a ****en joke. Time for a complete overhaul...

One of the worst decisions ever, anyone who advocates it should stop following Football altogether.

No, it always evens out itself during the season and has been at the same level for many a year now. Putting yourself into position of needing luck with umpiring to win the game means you aren't good enough to get the 4 points. Nothing 'veiled' about your whinge by the way.

Lol, try winning your first final for starters.....

This man speaks the truth. It was pathetic we challenged Daisy's hit on Armo, challenging now would be beyond comprehension.

Nah, I think the whinging about umpiring has hit rock bottom. Admittedly last 15 minutes of the Derby was bewildering to say the least.

That was the moment I've lost all respect for Hayes. Also how Armitage's head high high contact was considered accidental is beyond me, MRP are obviously looking after St Kilda and wants them in the finals and so do I :)

50 meter penalty for interchange infringement is the dumbest current rule in the game.

That maybe so but the most critical part here is the difference in trajectories and points of impact. Corey spun Steven for about 180 degrees while Kozi more or less simply dumped Duncan.

I actually agree with Pluggers' sulking for once, Corey's tackle looked by far the most dangerous of the 3 that came under scrutiny. http://www.afl.com.au/Video/tabid/76/contentid/365516/invoke/Default.aspx

Nah dude, only one difference - Daisy one week, Selwood four. Enjoy.

In all seriousness, despite not risking much Thomas' appeal was more ludicrous, 3 or 4 weeks doesn't make much difference and as Selwood was high up in Brownlow markets it was worth a hail marry challenge IMO

Considering AFL didn't suspend Judd for deliberately elbowing Pavlich in the scone these appeals are not as outrageous as they seem:thumbsu:

Keep on showing us how much it hurts.

The impacts were assessed differently. Keep on humiliating yourself, love seeing your posts full of agony.

So many cringe-worthy posts on this page alone. I'm far from a Selwood fan but from the vision available all I can distinguish Guerra lunging at him and Selwood giving him one. Its irrelevant whether it was a forearm, a fist or an elbow it was not a behind play act of thuggery. Was simply a...

You really think posting tripe in every Collingwood related thread hides or diminishes your suffering??? You really need to get over it.

"Unlisted"- the definition of soft. take a walk now coward :o

Spot on and unlike Hocking's strike this was assessed as a low impact. Thomas was never ever gonna get more than 2 weeks for his actions. There are plenty of other ridiculous MRP verdicts to bitch and moan about, even after this round.

/thread

That was an obvious wrong decision, umpire was probably stunned by Maxwell's actions as most of us were. I find all the talk about the momentum swing pretty funny though, I guess I'm just not used to loser mentality. By the way Malthouse obviously felt guilty about that umpiring blunder and...

So no more "players have stopped" or "I've blown time on" bullshit?

Geez I love the main board- everyone's saying the decision was correct means we're sulking, AFL admits it was wrong means we're still sulking, Toovey caves his face on Hawkins knee means he was stupid and we were lucky not to have a free paid against us, Didak gets tripped by Stokes thread ends...

Will somebody dare to provide this man an answer?