Search results for query: *

I can't believe this thread is seven pages long without one of these:

Agreed, and he even rolls off him once they hit the ground. Free kick, move on. Just watched the vision again and respectfully disagree. He lands on his back first and then rolls away/off Amon. But, it is just a bad tackle and warrants a free kick, that's all.

Disagree with those saying that NicNat doesn't fall on top of Amon, because he clearly does from the vision on page 1 of this thread, however that is a free kick for in the back, and nothing more. West Coast have to contest this, surely.

From all the still shots in here it looks like the ‘bump’ was delivered to Merrett’s body/shoulder. The head contact appears to be more Douglas’s left arm that comes up and connects Merrett’s chin/nose area, hence the bleeding from the mouth. I know it is all part of the bumping action, but...

Yeah, ok.

Think you will find the Hawks tried to plead guilty to lesser charge of 'aggressive wrestling' or some s**t to get a reduced sentence too. It wasn't like he just pleaded not guilty your honour. Anyhow, Boomer is now in the hands of John Burgess and his MRP's Wheel of Fortune. Good luck with that.

Did you read his testimony when trying to get off his eye gouging charge at the tribunal?

I'm with you TFS, I thought Tuohy missed him. However, I would like to see a replay of it too, before condemning Goddard.

I liked it, but Stevie J's problem will be the MRP will say he had an alternative which was to tackle given Hanley had the ball. People comparing this to Hodge are delusional. I'm guessing here, and let's face it who would really know, the MRP will cite it as Reckless, High Contact, Low (maybe...

Let's face it, rule changes the past 5 years are slowly but surely killing this game. I find it harder and harder to watch. I'm sure the young folk won't care less as it will be what they are used to, but us "oldies" don't appreciate some of the ridiculous rules introduced recently.

Just a touch over confident like your players last night!! The rest of your post I agree with completely.

Oh CMON, flop them out and show us how big they are:thumbsu:

He has a history of being happy to acknowledge Hawthorn umpire errors though, so I'm not convinced.

Puopolo had no prior, just ask Mitch Duncan.....maybe he was blindsided?:eek:

Yeah sure, just like Lewis had his priors wiped after Monfries admitted to diving. I think not. I'm completely with The Sheik here, nothing in this contest at all. It's footy, get over it and move on before we start wearing bibs and be restricted in which zones we are allowed to go into.

If he ends up with 269 points he gets 2 weeks doesn't he? Not saying he shouldn't get cited, but surely no worse than Kelly's, and he got how many?

There fixed that for you.

Re: Scarlett reported for striking You can't possibly compare a deliberate punch directed at an opponents jaw to a bump, surely. It will get assessed as most have said already, Intentional, High and either Low or Medium impact. Scarlett is perhaps a little lucky he didn't connect ala BBBH...

Vozzo. If we can avoid S Ryan on Friday it would also be a bonus.

Just watched the MRP video, and agree with what you say above. I hope the MRP can assess future similar instances like this one:thumbsu:

Are those photos blocked for Swans supporters on here? On that first picture, and I'm assuming Monfries dropped the ball when first hit by Goodes, he surely should have tackled, hits him high, and therefore will be cited. Riewoldt was done on this recently, and Buddy repeatedly. Goodes is in...

Herald Sun http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/chris-dawes-in-danger-for-anzac-day/story-e6frf9jf-1226041016100

This whole arc thing amuses me. I bet I could find at least one player at every club that 'uses an arc' especially when they are kicking from or outside their kicking range. It's not just a rule for Buddy, it's across the whole league. Yes, Buddy probably uses the arc when he is inside his...

Haven't seen the game yet Grim, but I read that the Official ran through the mark. Not sure whether that makes the free right or not though?

Have another look. You are kidding right??