Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. philthy05

    Strategy Trade and List .Management thread 5 (...the post coitus cigarette. Edition)

    Im a massive critic of jake Neade. In saying that he isn't any better or worse than what you think I just have a strong dislike for small forwards who are small. I don't know what the AFLs obsession is with small fast guys in the forward line. I would rather play a guy who can do all that but...
  2. philthy05

    Strategy Trade and List .Management thread 5 (...the post coitus cigarette. Edition)

    I really don't know what the club would be looking for. In my mind something like pick 22- 33.
  3. philthy05

    Strategy Trade and List .Management thread 5 (...the post coitus cigarette. Edition)

    Port aren't going to part with him for peanuts.
  4. philthy05

    Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

    Since you're so worried about outsiders here I will **** off, since you've asked me to repeatedly. If anyone on this board wants to come over and chat on the port board they are welcome. I'll make sure not to jump on them and tell them to **** off.
  5. philthy05

    Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

    Where did I make any assumptions ?
  6. philthy05

    Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

    How am I in the wrong here? You said if you could get Cloke and Trengove and only cost player X and player y etc. you never included a first rounder in that statement that you have now included in your later statement. I pointed out i didn't believe they were enough to land Trengove unless a...
  7. philthy05

    Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

    Can't see Trengove leaving. Seems pretty committed, so would be a shock to me. Would you give up a chb not yet in his prime for a pick in the 20's? heck no. Much less a contracted one. I'll go ahead and smash your dreams by telling you there is no way you can turn Jong and hrovat into...
  8. philthy05

    Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

    There is a mob down the road that would take cheaters in with open arms #tippettgate #taliasarecheats
  9. philthy05

    Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

    Agree. I think he is a much better pick up for a team that would use him in the centre. As I've noted earlier in my post on the outside he is ok , and certainly above most mids you would describe as inside mids , but not a great user by foot on the outside. It's hard to describe it though. He...
  10. philthy05

    Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

    Is contracted. Port would only likely move on a contracted young player with promise if they needed the currency for another move beyond the picks they already have available. Would take your second pick to do it(32 ish?) Your third (48-52?) just couldn't do anything for us we couldn't do...
  11. philthy05

    Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

    Why would port do that? No reason from their POV. I suspect Hrovat suffers from the " small guy so let's play him as a small forward but he gets exposed there and is better suited to playing as a mid pity about the height" kind of player. We already have one of those. 176cm Sam Gray who when we...
  12. philthy05

    Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

    Aaron young 22 yrs old , 42 afl games , 188cm midfielder / flanker. Good on the inside he has a knack for being able to stand up in tackles and release a hand pass. An elite trait of being able to stand and keep arms free and releasing hand pass when it suits him to a target rather than an...
  13. philthy05

    Mega Thread Trade and List Management discussion

    Off the top of my head only kruuzer , luey and Zac smith are out of contract. Witts could be available as part of an on trade to get picks for gws. Martin might be looking for a home. Teams would be enquiring about lobbe although hinks seems to want two rucks although who knows. Zac Clarke...
Back
Top