Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. Gibbke

    Research Correcting historical match starting times

    The AFL stats book they release every year designates games as day, twilight and night, or at least they used to twenty years ago when twilight was much rarer. They had them in the head to head stats...seemed like they had an official stance...
  2. Gibbke

    Research Correcting historical match starting times

    I'm interested in what this does to the classification of day, twilight and night games... I call any match played before 3:20pm a day game, between 3:20 and 5:00 a twilight game, and after that a night match. If it's before midday, it's a morning match, even if it started at 11:59! The...
  3. Gibbke

    What would an ideal Tasmanian league look like?

    Deloraine percentage 30, Scottsdale 11, both winless after five rounds...some spasmodic bursts of good footy in the last decade from the Roos, none at all from the Magpies... If they get thrown into the pit with North Launceston next year, it could be pretty ugly... Four team comp. Only South...
  4. Gibbke

    Research Data gaps + big projects

    The war created havoc with lower leagues. Burnie were leading the ladder undefeated after R3 in 1940, but didn't have a team at all the next week because they all joined the army! Comp was disbanded immediately. Wynyard were on top of their league by a street, 1941 I think, but the army...
  5. Gibbke

    Research Data gaps + big projects

    Mine is all about Tassie. The mission is every score of every game ever played in the state in the one place. If it's Top Tier - TFL, NT, NW or rep, it gets the full treatment - 4Q's, venue, attendance, date, winner and margin, goalkickers and full teams...the only thing missing from your...
  6. Gibbke

    New NTFA Premier Division 2025

    Four team comp. You know that South would be able to get themselves up to par, and the best facilities in the country part of Northern Tassie are at Longford, plus you know they'd want to get back on top if it was viable for them...the first sixty years of both the NTFA and TFL looked like...
  7. Gibbke

    Old Scholars Thread

    Were you there? I've just got back home to FNQ after spending the week in Tassie, and was based for the last few days right next to KGV until this morning. Was thinking of going to the TCA just to get a footy fix last night, being the only live game on...!
  8. Gibbke

    Cricket things that annoy you

    Two completely different scenarios. WSC was born by frustration with archaic boards demanding sacrifices and professionalism from players and not giving anything back. The ramifications of those years totally transformed cricket, unrecognisable from what it was only a decade earlier, and while...
  9. Gibbke

    Cricket things that annoy you

    Cricket things that annoy me...f###, where do I start... 1) The Mankad is a legit dismissal. Every argument against it is bullshit. 2) T20. 3) CA. 4) Bilateral ODI series. 5) 2 test series. 6) Super overs. 7) People using the term "spirit of cricket" to justify their own self serving biases...
  10. Gibbke

    Opinion Team Jumper

    A little disappointed in the jumper, but the above are probably right, they'll tweak it... The red needs darkening, kinda like the paint job on the cheap Gibson ripoff Aria doubleneck I bought decades ago...supposed to be the deep burgundy Jimmy Page had on his, but it had more in common with a...
  11. Gibbke

    How scared are you of St Kilda this year?

    It's gas, isn't it?
  12. Gibbke

    How scared are you of St Kilda this year?

    I've got a gut feeling about the Saints this year...
  13. Gibbke

    West Coast are the only non VIC club to win a premiership without concessions

    That's the only match that doesn't follow a strong top team home advantage rule. Bearing in mind this thread is about concessions influencing the naming of a premier, show me where that's influenced the result of this single game...? Like I said, nothing is stopping interstaters from winning an...
  14. Gibbke

    NO TROLLS Racism Bombshell Claim - Carlton and Essendon Named

    I would have been all over this a year ago. Then we had the referendum, and I gave up on Australia, knowing amongst many other things that threads like this would appear again...with the same embarrassing responses...
  15. Gibbke

    What would an ideal Tasmanian league look like?

    King Island would be uncompetitive. These days, they play around a dozen a side, with open registrations in case a visitor who says he played footy once visits that weekend...! If you were ranking the leagues, the numbers seem to show that the tiers below the four big comps stratify like this...
  16. Gibbke

    Opinion Team Jumper

    It has to be a V. Saw an Examiner selection of nine jumpers recently, all crap! This one comes close - I'd have the rose replaced with more green, and a double V straighter than yours but in the same position with both red or rose and a strong yellow, tapered and pointy at the cuffs but fuller...
  17. Gibbke

    Which Grand Final or Big Final was the '' one that got away '' For your Team?

    Some newbies will say 2012, but the Swans were the better team...Sydney would have been utterly justified in writing here about 2012 if Malceski missed and the Hawks got to the other end in time... But in 1984, the Hawks pretty much had the Bombers on toast for the first half, and held them to...
  18. Gibbke

    Hawthorn of the 1980's

    Before the 2015 GF, I went on a winning GF DVD splurge, watched the lot in the couple of weeks before, and only last week I've started a splurge on Kayo watching the GF's we'd lost, matches I haven't seen since those dark days...! Both times, I've been blown away by how good that guy was, which...
  19. Gibbke

    Finer Details

    Ploughing through the NTFL after I was given the rosters of a bunch of NTFL Records. Some various missing scores here, was wondering if anyone could help me fill them in: Saturday, May 6 - R06-89- Sat ULV () WYN () WYN* by R06 means round 6, 89 was the year. Ulverstone won this game via...
  20. Gibbke

    Greatest Dynasty of the 21st century - Lions vs Cats vs Hawks vs Tigers

    They gave them space but they didn't use it. Those players had already been recruited, and the squad took pay cuts knowing they were on a good thing...
  21. Gibbke

    Greatest Dynasty of the 21st century - Lions vs Cats vs Hawks vs Tigers

    Man for man the Hawks and Tigers weren't as good as the other two, but Clarkson-spawned teams and coaches tend to play game plans extremely well. It took until 2011 for me to admit the Cats might have outshone the Lions...twice they beat serious juggernauts in finals, whereas the Lions, after...
  22. Gibbke

    The 2023 Grand Final vs The 1993 Grand Final - 30 Years on

    Never said they were weak, I just said they weren't as good as the dynasties, including their own side, from a decade earlier. And if the OP, some millennial Collingwood supporter, gets to make a blanket statement saying the quality of footy is better than ever before because his team won it...
  23. Gibbke

    The 2023 Grand Final vs The 1993 Grand Final - 30 Years on

    They had a burst of good form in 2022, and benefitted from all of the other contenders being less consistent or lucky with injuries than in the years either side of the flag. There hasn't been a side as good as the Tigers at their best since they took out 2019, the only team worthy of such a...
  24. Gibbke

    The 2023 Grand Final vs The 1993 Grand Final - 30 Years on

    Unsuccessful Geelong sides? I'm directly comparing the 2022 side with the team from ten years earlier who won three premierships. Didn't say a word about the 1990's...
  25. Gibbke

    The 2023 Grand Final vs The 1993 Grand Final - 30 Years on

    Maybe he wrote a book. F###, if I did that, I would...
  26. Gibbke

    The 2023 Grand Final vs The 1993 Grand Final - 30 Years on

    You seriously think that team was as good as the one from a decade earlier...?!? Someone is going to be ranked number 1 every season, pretty weak argument...just ask the guy who topped Adelaide grade cricket's batting averages the season after Bradman retired...
  27. Gibbke

    General TSL Talk

    Numbers suggest South in 2013 can't be discounted...! That squad utterly monstered lesser teams and regularly took out their main rivals - it also went through an unsettling period knowing their team was doomed before making the GF, and afterwards most of them signed up for a completely new...
  28. Gibbke

    Finer Details

    Huon FA 1977 - can anyone list the scores of the three Kingston v Huonville games? Specifically, it appears that Huonville needed to win at least one to make the finals, which they did, but my source says Kingston won all three. Not discounting the possibility that match points were taken from...
  29. Gibbke

    The 2023 Grand Final vs The 1993 Grand Final - 30 Years on

    I look at that Cats team that won the GF in 2022, and then compare it to the one which won three a decade ago, as well as the Hawks and Swans of that era, and not in any circumstances would I rate it as even close! After years of missing out, bombing out of finals due to inadequacy, they took...
  30. Gibbke

    Top 10 coaches in the history of the game?

    Of course I'll say Clarkson. But after reading an article about Norm Smith that appeared in the GF Replay Record of 2010 (they had five days to put out another nearly 200 page record, amazing job!), you'd be hard pressed to argue against that guy...
Back
Top