GWS Giants
Premiership quality football from about halfway through the season. They would want to win a flag in the next year or two before Coniglio (30) Whitfield (29) Kelly (29) are past their best. Tom Green should be looking at Dusty / Petracca finals series in prior years. Love they...
Post your predicted ladder for the 2024 AFL season here!
There will be a score at the end.
2023 ladder prediction results
2022 ladder prediction results
2021 ladder prediction results
2020 ladder prediction results
2019 ladder prediction results
2018 ladder prediction results
Can you beat...
Pretty happy with my predictions this year aside from Collingwood. Always get them wrong.
:whitecheck:
They were actually really good through the year. But lost two finals despite lots more I50s and scoring shots, simply on bad goalkicking.
:whitecheck:
:crossmark:
Can't seem to get...
I had Giants 8th
“Tom Green is better than both Taranto and Hopper and much more skilful. Lots of really nice key position players and flankers. Don't know if Adam Kingsley can coach. If he can, then they should be good.”
Love Toby Bedford! Elite forward pressure is something this team has lacked and it makes such a difference across the field when you have it. Just a great team player.
So close to a home final. I’ve got two small kids and can’t get to games these days as it’s 60 minutes each way. But would...
I thought Milera lost track of Daniels defensively a couple of times but it wasn’t a total train wreck by any means. Still think he should be on the wing.
Did Thilthorpe ruck in the SANFL because he had to, or because we are now developing him as a ruckman? If we are developing him as a...
Melbourne
Brisbane
Western Bulldogs
Port Adelaide
Sydney
Geelong
St Kilda
GWS
Richmond
Carlton
Collingwood
Fremantle
Adelaide
Gold Coast
Essendon
West Coast
North Melbourne
Hawthorn
B Smith Butts Laird
HB Doedee Murray Dawson
C Milera Soligo Sholl
HF McHenry Fogarty Rankine
F McAdam Walker Rachelle
R O'Brien Crouch Berry
IC Thilthorpe Worrell Schoenberg Murphy
Crouch I hope will be super fit. He is a good footballer and 27, 28 later this season. Geelong would have him...
If someone else posted this then I missed it. Without having the full breakdown this is the best we get. I listed all players with more than 13 games played for the year, and votes for those we have them.
Player
Games
Votes
Votes per game
Rory Laird
20
118
5.9
Jordan Dawson
22
114
5.2...
Post your predicted ladder for the 2023 AFL season here!
There will be a score at the end.
2022 ladder prediction results
2021 ladder prediction results
2020 ladder prediction results
2019 ladder prediction results
2018 ladder prediction results
Can you beat last year's top 5?
PCORF - 68...
Interesting to see that of the contrarians, PCORF and Golumless were 1st and equal 2nd. crows dude as coach of the year with the totally out there predictions for equal 5th.
Surely no chance of a loss at home to West Coast. They are the worst team in 10 years. Their percentage is 49.9.
In GWS first year of 2012, percentage was 46. In 2013 it was 51. With a mix of top old, too young, and fillers. That is West Coast this year.
A loss here would be as bad a loss...
A significant challenge for the incoming coach will be the senior players' capability to adapt to a more AFL-level tactical gameplan.
Under Leon, for years it has just been gut busting hero ball. No real system or flow. Players hitting each contest one by one.
Now we have this established...
Currently sitting 4th on tackle differential at +5.8. I don’t think effort has been the problem.
Transition play as you say is the one but that might not happen overnight.
Disagree the problem is effort
The problem is at the strategic level. Everything is a grind, an arm wrestle. There hasn’t been any flow since 2016.
We decide to switch play from the D50; by the time we have switched the opposition is in a better position on the other wing than us.
Players...
Overdue.
Played with a real sense of flow in 2016, could easily have won the flag in that year.
Despite many gritty wins since then, have never replicated that flow and coherence since 2016. The last 5 years have been a grind.
Still loaded with talent. Hopefully, will now get a coach who...
I noticed that too.
Recall watching a GWS game years ago and Will Hoskin-Elliot did the same thing post mark, pre kick. Dunstall who was commentating called it “loser’s limp” and sure enough WHE missed the kick and then went for more stretches.
Loser’s limp.
One more for this week.
In round 5 Matt Crouch had 25 possessions. 5 were contested and 20 were uncontested. As I understand it, free kicks are included in contested possessions. Matt Crouch had 5 free kicks. Therefore he had zero contested possessions excluding free kicks. He also had...
Here's our defenders and their performance in defensive one-on-ones. (Not shown: difficulty of opponent.) Good numbers for Sholl.
givenName
surname
OneOnOnes
Losses
LossPercentage
Tom
Doedee
11
0
0
Lachlan
Sholl
5
0
0
Nick
Murray
5
0
0
Luke
Brown
8
2
26.66
Brodie
Smith
6
2
26.66...
Thought I'd bring back this thread with some occasional stats.
Here's our players ordered by AFL player rating points this year up to round 5.
1
2
3
4
5
Average
1
Taylor
Walker
23.9
20.7
22.3
2
Rory
Laird
8.5
19.1
17.8
15.13333
3
Jordan
Dawson
14.5
12.2
17.1
13.3
10.6...
I see it the same way. I think it might also help Hamill improve his game to spend 12 months being the hunter (applying forward pressure).
However the time to make that move would have been at the start of pre season.
Universal belief on this forum that players shouldn’t be pushed through niggles. Especially senior players, even more especially when we clearly aren’t in the hunt for anything.
Also just about universal optimism that Burgess is the man who will fix the things we don’t like
Now it turns out...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.