Search results for query: *

Interesting that former Richmond team mates, and journalists are split on this. Just want the trade period to get here so we can find out definitively.

Furute pick probably worth more to us next year that Zeke Uwland, an academy player, is in the draft and tipped currently to be in the top couple prospects.

Depends I suppose, where do they see Mac playing full time? If it is back, then they still need a 2nd ruck because you don't want to unsettle the backline putting Mac in the ruck. Himmelberg is a safe but uninspiring choice while Read develops, he probably needs another year of size putting on...

I assume he is off to PA, and is just waiting for them to drop out/win the premiership.

Sit in a forward pocket on $350k - $500k (according to the HS) for a year or two, hardly breaking the bank with the new cap and giving up no trade assets, don't mind this having a crack at it.

On $500k for 1-2 years, no issue with this at all.

Nice rivalry building with the Tigers. Been some spicy moments, Tom Lynch and Prestia leaving, Karmichael Hunt and Ando after the siren, Dimma and friends moving up.

I suppose what do you do, the market clearly dictated we needed to pay him and give him that security to stay. A 5+4 year contract with injury clauses built in is as safe as a long term contract in this day and age can get. Do you only offer him 4-5 years when others are offering him 8+ and...

Worth mentioning the big bucks won't kick in until 2026, he still has 2025 on his current rate.

Love it! Mac is so much fun to watch.

There is starting high, then there is starting way over the price that you are entering Dodoro territory.

I suppose the question is do you risk short term pain and missing out on these players to help us in the now, a critical time in our clubs history for benefit down the line? It's tricky, but what is correct, this is all damage we have done to ourselves with our awful trading previously, there...

Hard pass on that.

I would be HARD passing on Noble at 12, even 20 is rich.

Bowes was forced out because the club made horrendous cap decisions. Don't blame him one bit for leaving and wanting to get paid. Bonus is now he gets to compete in a preliminary final. Hasn't become the game breaker we had hoped but he is still a good player in a great team.

Club BnFs are a bit funny. They reward role players along side the best players on the team.

Should be in the round 1 team to provide some aid to Rowell on the inside.

Brisbane doing their best GC impersonation here.

A wild card Collingwood would have done better than this...

The same Smith who was a shell of himself in 2023 and people were asking for him to be dropped. Something in the Geelong water will no doubt get him up and going, but he was hardly at the peak of powers when he last played.

MCG breathing a big sigh of relief.

Lukosius ready to take that paycut...

I think they are the exception, not the rule.

Lukosius won't want to go to this team at this rate.

Tomlinson makes sense if we want to continue with the 3 tall defenders and Mac is going to stay as a forward.

Any rebrand probably will need to wait for the women's season to wrap up.

As much as some of us like to think on here, we don't do the trades. My point was making a public comment has no bearing on what a trade is going to look like, all that is done behind closed doors, where Campbell may be making similar comments reaffirming this. The Richmond list team aren't...

FWIW, I don't think what a list manager says in public has any impact on a trade outside of riling up the masses. I don't think a club is looking to a public statement to find the stance on a player or trade.

I'm glad people on here know our salary cap situation, what a relief I can refer to these experts to know where the Suns cap sits.

You give him 1 more year to see if you can get the best out of him. If it doesn't come off, just trade him next year instead, there will still be a market for him